My startup might not make it — should I sell?

If you're worried the company could fail, selling to protect some value is a legitimate instinct — but it's often hardest to do exactly when you'd most want to. Here's a clear-eyed look.

The uncomfortable truth about timing

Secondary demand dries up precisely when a company looks shaky — buyers vanish, or only at steep discounts. The best time to de-risk is usually before trouble is obvious, when a tender or buyer is still available at a fair price. If problems are already visible, selling may be hard or cheap.

Signals worth noticing

Down rounds, bridge financings or difficulty raising. See down round and bridge round.
A heavy preference stack ahead of you, which can leave common holders with little even in a sale. Model the waterfall.
Layoffs, leadership churn, or missed milestones.

None is proof of failure — companies recover — but together they raise the case for taking some risk off the table while you can.

What you can realistically do

Act early if you're going to act. Liquidity is easiest before trouble is widely known.
Check your downside. A tall preference stack may mean your common is worth little in a modest sale — know this before deciding.
Sell a portion, not necessarily all. Protecting some value still leaves upside if the company recovers.
Be realistic on price. In a wobble, expect deeper discounts — or no buyer.

If the company is already failing, selling may not be possible. In that case, focus on the tax side — for example, whether a worthless-stock loss could offset other gains. Take professional advice.

Frequently asked questions

Can I sell my shares if my startup is failing?

It's often difficult. Secondary buyers tend to disappear, or only buy at steep discounts, exactly when a company looks troubled. The practical window to de-risk is usually before problems are widely known, which is why acting early matters if you're worried.

How do I know if my common shares are worth anything?

Look at the liquidation preference stack ahead of you: if investors are owed large multiples before common holders get paid, your shares can be worth little in a modest exit even if the headline price seems high. Modelling the exit waterfall shows this clearly.

What if the shares become worthless?

If the company fails and the stock is worthless, you may be able to claim a capital loss to offset other gains, depending on your jurisdiction and situation. This is a tax question best handled with a professional — it won't recover your investment but can soften the blow.

Get the numbers before you decide

Free, no sign-up: estimate what your stake is worth, the cost to exercise, and whether you can sell.

Value my equity (free) → · All free tools → · Glossary →

When you're ready to go deeper, there's an optional Equity Toolkit and Report.