Selling startup shares

Who buys private startup shares — and how to actually sell yours

The first question every seller asks is "who would even buy these?" There are really only four kinds of buyer. Knowing which one fits your situation is half the battle.

Part of our guide to finding a buyer for private shares.

If you hold shares in a private startup and want to turn some into cash, the honest starting point is that there's no public market and no queue of buyers. But there are, reliably, four places a buyer comes from. Work through them in order.

1. The company itself (a buyback or tender)

Some companies buy shares back, or periodically run a tender that lets holders sell a slice. It's the cleanest route when it exists — but it needs the company to have spare cash, and most small European startups don't. Worth asking; don't count on it.

2. Existing shareholders and investors

Often your first real stop. Your shareholder agreement probably gives the company or existing investors a right of first refusal (ROFR) anyway, so you'll likely have to offer them the shares first. Some will buy to consolidate their position or avoid being diluted later. You can even propose flexible terms — for example, a purchase paid in instalments with interest, rather than all cash up front.

3. The investor in your next funding round

This is the underrated one. When a company is raising, an incoming investor can buy your existing shares instead of (or alongside) new ones — it gets them exposure without creating new, dilutive shares, and it gets you paid. Selling around a funding round is often the best-timed window there is, because someone is already setting a fresh price on the company.

It's also leverage. If you're leaving, tell the founders early that you intend to sell. They generally won't want a departing shareholder setting a low price on their shares right before a raise — which is often enough to get a buyback or an introduction to the incoming investor moving.

4. A private individual investor

When the company can't buy, the insiders pass, and there's no round imminent, the remaining buyer is a private investor who wants access to the company. Many good private companies never open a round to individuals, so a secondary is one of the few ways in — which is exactly why the right buyer is often glad to hear from you. The hard part is finding them — which is why understanding how the market works, and getting your valuation and paperwork ready, is what makes the difference.

Expect a discount — and be honest

Whichever buyer you find, a private, minority, all-cash sale happens at a discount to the headline valuation — commonly a meaningful one, and steeper when the company is early or struggling. That's normal (more in what discount is fair). And sell honestly: if there are material problems, a buyer is entitled to know. A clean, transparent sale is the one that actually closes — and the one that doesn't come back to bite you.

Thinking about selling?

It's worth understanding what you hold, what it might be worth and how a private transfer works before you act. Start with the free equity starter kit, or go deeper with the equity toolkit.

Get the equity toolkit — $39
US edition · instant PDF, no sign-up · EU edition →

Prefer to read up first? The Equity Toolkit (€39) walks through clearing restrictions and running the sale, step by step.

Free: the Equity Starter Kit

The plain-English glossary and the essentials to get started — instant download, no email required.

Download the free kit →

Further reading

General, independent references on how private-company shares and options work. We're not affiliated with any of them.

How we keep this accurate. We write from primary sources — official tax authorities (HMRC, IRS), financial regulators (FCA, SEC) and company filings — date every page, and review them regularly. This is independent, educational information, and deliberately not a substitute for professional tax, legal or financial advice on your own situation.

General information only — not financial, tax or legal advice. Every situation is different; check your own share and option agreements and take professional advice before selling. PrivateTechShares is an education and tools service: it is not a broker or marketplace, does not introduce buyers and sellers, does not hold funds, and does not execute or advise on transactions.